Where to Find the Best Pizza in the Spartanburg Area

Posted on | 3 Comments

What’s for dinner tonight? A home-cooked meal is always nice, but it’s also time-consuming. What is something that everybody in the family can enjoy and it can be made simply for picky eaters or with more exotic choices for adults? Pizza is a meal everyone can agree on and after all, National Pizza Day is February 9th, so go celebrate! 

Best Pizza In The Area

If you are going out to eat with your family, co-workers, hosting a birthday party, or just want to grab a slice, Spartanburg offers several options to fill your pizza craving.

Instead of opting for your traditional delivery or carryout pizza place, why not give one of the pizza restaurants our readers love a try!

Pi-Squared Pizza

Sidewall Pizza

187 North Church Street, Spartanburg | 864.327.9602

Why It’s good: It took me a while to try Sidewall Pizza, but once I did I was hooked! The announcement that they were coming to Spartanburg was met by a lot of excitement in our house. You don’t even have to take my word for it – when we recently asked readers on social media, this was the most popular choice. Sidewall offers customers free pizza for their birthdays, vegan options, gluten-free options and more. Read more about why I love this locally owned pizza place with this review .

I love sidewall. Ingredients are always fresh. The crust is the best. They have “different” kinds of pizza. They treat kids awesome (always bring mine a cup of gold fish), and the homemade ice cream…amazing.

Erica C.

Sidewall, definitely. They pile on the toppings and those breadsticks are to die for!

Danielle B.

Sidewall…bc I loooove their salad options!!!

Tia J.

Sidewall…bc I loooove their salad options!!!

Kody W.

Sidewall – bc gluten free and their ranch is bomb.

Eva F.K.

Rapid Fired Pizza

1707 John B White Sr Boulevard, Spartanburg |864.216.8186

Why it’s good: Have you ever looked longingly at the list of pizza toppings and wished you could just get whatever you wanted on your pizza, instead of just boring cheese and pepperoni? That’s what draws our readers to Rapid Fired Pizza, the chance to enjoy whatever you want on your own pizza while still making the kids happy! Personal size pizzas are prepared in front of you and cooked lightning fast. We were one of the first to try Rapid Fired Pizza when it opened and it’s been a huge hit with families.

Rapid Fire bc they have so many options, are affordable, and super fast!

Summer L.

La Taverna

120 Dorman Commerce Drive, Spartanburg | 864.576.8660

Why it’s good: Not only do they have some really tasty pizza, they also have some of the best Italian cuisine in Spartanburg! They offer a kid’s menu or you can leave the kids at home and enjoy a nice date night meal. It’s a great place to go no matter the occasion.

La Taverna in Spartanburg. Closest to Long Island pizza here in SC. Love them!

Crystal R.

Venus Pie Pizzeria

400 East Main Street, Spartanburg | 864.582.4200

Why it’s good: Venus Pie has a loyal following locally. They make their own crust and sauce and the slices they sell are HUGE. Conveniently located downtown, you can spend some time at the park and then head to Venus Pie for a slice as big as your head.

Venus pie hands down!!/p>Erin E.

Venus Pie closest to the Pizza ‘s I used to get growing up in PA

Darryl H.

Pi-Squared Pizza

1802 Drayton Road, Spartanburg |864.586.2525

Why it’s good: If you are looking for an alternative to New York-style pizza, Pi-Squared is the place to go. They offer pan-style pizza, made famous in Detroit as well as a thin crust option.

Pi squared. Michigan style!

Carol U.

Pi Squared (it’s thick but not too much bread and crunchy) and Manny’s (it’sjust awesome)!!

Alicia R.

Where is your favorite place to get a pizza in the Spartanburg area?

About the Author
Melanie is a native New Yorker, who landed in the Upstate by way of Florida. She is the mom to two awesome kids, and the three of them love going on adventures! She enjoys sharing her finds with friends and loves even more that she can share them with Kidding Around readers! She can be found on Instagram @figuringthisoutdotcom
Notify of
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Jeb Klein
Jeb Klein
1 year ago

I like the pizza in warmers at the checkout at walmart. It’s so good, I wanna slap someone

Chrystal Randolph
Chrystal Randolph
11 months ago

Della Venturas in Greer is the absolute best. 🖤


[…] what they think the list should look like. If you can’t decide, try starting with a “Top Ten Places To Eat Pizza In Spartanburg” challenge. People are VERY passionate about pizza, and no matter what you choose, and who […]